Sooner or later, someone in the business asks whether ChatGPT recommends the company. You can type the question in yourself, but you get one answer from one session, and a new session may say something else. A growing group of AI visibility tools sells a more systematic version of that check, at prices that run from under $100 per month to custom enterprise contracts.
The catch is that the thing being measured is unstable. In a SparkToro study based on 2,961 runs of 12 prompts, the researchers found less than a 1 in 100 chance that ChatGPT or Google's AI would give the same list of brands in any two responses. A tool can report that variation accurately and still leave you with a number that is easy to misread.
This guide compares published plans from Profound, Peec AI, Semrush, Ahrefs and Otterly, explains what the metrics can and cannot tell you, and sets out a short test for choosing. Pricing was checked on each vendor's own site on November 2, 2026. This is a comparison of published information, not a hands-on review of the tools.
What Do AI Visibility Tools Actually Measure?
Most of these tools work the same way at the core. They send a set of prompts to AI engines on a schedule, store the answers, and look for your brand and your competitors in them. From that, they calculate a few common measures:
- Visibility: the share of answers that mention your brand.
- Share of voice: your mentions compared with those of competitors in the same answers.
- Citations: the web pages an engine links to or names as sources.
- Sentiment: how the answer describes your brand.
The important limit is that these are samples. A tool can only report on the prompts it runs, and those prompts are chosen by you or estimated by the vendor. None of this tells you how many real people asked that question, what they asked before it, or whether they then bought anything.
Why Are AI Visibility Numbers So Unstable?
A search ranking is relatively stable: run the same query twice and you usually see a similar page. AI answers are generated fresh. In the SparkToro test, 600 volunteers ran prompts through ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI results. Besides the 1 in 100 figure for matching lists, the author estimated it would take about 1,000 runs to see two lists in the same order.
That does not make measurement pointless. The same research found that a brand's overall presence could hold up across many differently worded prompts. In one test of 142 human-written prompts about headphones, Bose, Sony, Sennheiser and Apple appeared 55% to 77% of the time. The author's conclusion is the most useful rule in this category: visibility percentage across many prompts run repeatedly is a reasonable metric, but a “ranking position in AI” is not.
It is worth noting the study's limits. It is not peer reviewed, it was run with an AI tracking company, and the author discloses that connection. Still, it gives you a practical standard: ask any vendor how many times each prompt is run and how much the score moves from one period to the next.
How Do the Main AI Visibility Tools Compare?
These are the published details on each vendor's site. Plans change often in this category, so confirm them before you buy.
- Profound: enterprise focused, with custom pricing and up to 9 answer engines. A free trial covers 50 prompts, run daily for 7 days, on ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews.
- Peec AI: Starter is $95 per month for 50 prompts, Pro is $245 for 150, and Advanced is $495 for 350. These plans include ChatGPT, AI Mode, AI Overviews, Copilot, Gemini and Naver AI, with 3 active models. Perplexity and several API models are listed under the custom Enterprise plan.
- Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit: $99 per month with 25 tracked prompts, 1 project and 1 domain. Adding 50 more prompts costs $60 per month. There is no free trial. The documentation names ChatGPT and Google AI Mode for prompt tracking and brand performance.
- Ahrefs Brand Radar: offers two products. Custom Prompts starts at $50 per month and tracks prompts you define, while the AI Visibility Index is listed at $199 per month and draws on a prebuilt index of 525 million prompts with no setup.
- Otterly: often described in third-party comparisons as a low cost starting point, but its pricing page would not load when this guide was checked, so confirm its current plans directly.
How Should You Compare Pricing?
Monthly price says little by itself, because the plans do not count the same thing. Dividing price by tracked prompts gives a better starting point. Peec AI works out to about $1.90 per prompt on Starter and $1.41 on Advanced. Semrush works out to about $3.96 per prompt on the base plan, and its add-on works out to $1.20 per prompt.
Peec's monthly answer allowance shows how usage adds up. Its Starter plan lists 4,500 AI answers, which equals 50 prompts across 3 models over 30 days. Use the same math on any tool: prompts, multiplied by engines, multiplied by runs.
Treat per prompt cost as a rough screen only. Engines, run frequency and reporting differ between products, so these figures are not like for like. Ahrefs and Profound are harder to compare this way, since part of their value sits in a prebuilt index or a custom contract.
Which AI Visibility Tool Fits Your Situation?
- You already pay for Semrush or Ahrefs: start with its add-on, since your SEO data and AI data then sit in one place.
- You are a small team tracking one brand: a self-serve plan with around 50 prompts is usually enough to learn whether this data changes your decisions.
- You want a quick read with no prompt setup: a prebuilt index is faster, but the prompts are not ones you chose.
- You operate across several markets: check country limits first. Peec's Starter plan covers one country, for instance.
- You are a large brand with compliance needs: an enterprise contract may be justified, as long as a trial shows the data changes decisions.
How Do You Test a Tool Before Committing?
Ignore the dashboard demo and run a small, controlled test. Profound's free trial makes this possible without a purchase, and monthly plans keep the cost of a paid test low.
- Write 20 to 30 prompts in three groups: category questions, problem questions and comparison questions. Include prompts your customers really use, taken from sales calls and support tickets.
- Add two or three competitors, including one you expect to beat you.
- Run the same prompts in each tool you are testing, for at least two weeks.
- Check a sample of 10 stored answers by hand against the live engine. Results will differ, but the tool should not be describing a completely different picture.
- Compare week to week movement. If the score swings widely with no change on your side, treat small changes as noise.
- Look at the cited pages. This is often the most actionable output, since it shows which sources an engine relies on.
Before the test begins, write down what decision the data could change. If no number would change your plan, you do not need the subscription yet.
What Should You Do With the Data?
A visibility score does not improve itself. The useful work happens when the data points to a specific gap:
- Your brand is missing from category answers: strengthen clear, factual pages on what you do and who it is for.
- Competitors get cited from third-party pages: review those sources and find out where your brand can legitimately be included.
- Answers describe you wrongly: correct the information on your own site and on the external profiles that repeat it.
- Answers cite old pages: update them, or give the engine a better page to use.
These actions overlap heavily with solid GEO and SEO work. Report AI visibility next to organic traffic, referral traffic from AI engines and leads, and treat it as a directional signal rather than a revenue metric.
Where to Start This Week
Write your prompt list before you open a pricing page. It costs nothing, it forces you to define the questions that matter, and it makes any trial far more useful. Then test one tool for two weeks and judge it on whether it changed a decision.
If you want help building the prompt set and turning the results into a content plan, our SEO and AI search service covers this work. Contact us to talk through your situation.
Frequently asked questions
What is an AI visibility tool?
It is software that sends a set of prompts to AI engines such as ChatGPT and Google AI Mode on a schedule, then reports how often your brand and competitors appear, which sources get cited, and how the answers describe you.
How much do AI visibility tools cost?
As of November 2026, published plans include Peec AI from $95 per month, Semrush's toolkit at $99 per month, and Ahrefs Custom Prompts from $50 per month. Profound's main plan is custom priced. Prices change often, so confirm them with the vendor.
Are AI visibility scores accurate?
They can accurately record the answers a tool received, but those answers vary from run to run. SparkToro's research supports using visibility percentage across many repeated prompts as a metric, and it rejects the idea of a fixed ranking position in AI.
Do I need an AI visibility tool?
Only if the data could change a decision. Start by writing 20 to 30 real customer prompts and checking them by hand. Pay for a tool when manual checks become too slow or you need trends over time.
Need help with this?
Growthtrait can help you put this into practice. Let's talk about your goals.
Contact us




